Is Sarah Palin really a babbling idiot?

| No Comments | No TrackBacks
I tuned in to the Vice Presidential debate tonight but had to watch it with the sound muted--sometimes the sound from the TV upsets my 2 month old son. Watching a political event with closed-captioning and the sound off is an entirely different experience than with the sound on..

Immediately I was struck by how strange Sarah Palin's speech read over closed-captioning. It was filled with sentence fragments, run-on sentences, and awkward topic changes. It was very challenging to try and figure out what point she was trying to make. It read like she was jacked up on caffeine and/or extremely nervous.

After about 15 minutes I started to wonder if the person typing in the closed-captioning was biased--were they making Palin read worse than she sounded? Were they intentionally dropping words or periods to make it read like she was a babbling idiot? Are the deaf hearing our candidates through a biased closed-caption writer??? I had to un-mute the debate for a moment and hear for myself.

To my profound astonishment, I discovered that Sarah Palin sounded worse un-muted than she did over the closed-captioning. The person doing the closed-captioning was actually doing her a tremendous favor: In many cases they were actually completing her sentences or omitting repeated statements she made in her dialog. Although while reading the closed-captioning it was a challenge to decipher the point she was trying to make, you could find some context in her words, whereas in her verbal speech I felt like I was being talked-over by a sports announcer desperate to avoid dead air.

Un-muted the sentence fragments and rambling-on kind-of works for her, in sort-of a "I'm George W. Bush and I have invented-ed new words" kind-of way. (I just made up a new tense of "invent" right there). You interpret the rambling as coming from someone who's "Down to Earth" and has a "Nice Personality." For some people I'm sure they identify with it, because that's how most of us sound when put into a stressful situation.

But over closed-captioning, she sounds like a babbling idiot.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:

Leave a comment

Myself

Projects

Monthly Archives

Photos

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Robert W. Rose published on October 2, 2008 9:28 PM.

Broadband Data Improvement Act a bit of a misnomer? was the previous entry in this blog.

Disastrous consequences is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.